For those wanting serious critiques only!!
Published on October 23, 2010 By teddybearcholla In Wallpapers

 Thought I would start this thread in the hopes that there will be good and serious critiques.   I can be your first *victim* IR  or whomever wishes to give me direction!!!    This is in progress....it is a photo I took and then added the little ghosties...which may or may not work. 

 


Comments (Page 7)
18 PagesFirst 5 6 7 8 9  Last
on Oct 28, 2010

Hi Karen

If we are to believe the mist is following the guy and passing under his armpit, then the nist would be going in every direction incliding around the other side of the arm and over his right hand.The mist on the grass looks out of place a bit, or it needs more, all around over his arm, hand and the grass in front, which may be a better idea. I like your imagination in this piece. The  little green things hanging down need darkening to blend in better Great eyes. Just some food for thought. I'll have to follow this to see how it comes along.

Cheers Gary

on Oct 28, 2010

The deal with the mist is that my idea here is that he's coming out of the ground, there is mist behind him and a little bit in front of him.  You really think the Spanish moss needs to be darkened?  In real life it's much lighter than the trees it hangs from...kind of a dusty gray color.

on Oct 28, 2010

When I was writing the comment it was only showing 3/4 of the picture and when I finshed the entire pic was there. That was wierd. I stil have the same suggestions. I agree with Frankie also about working the corners, some blood would be a nice effect.  

on Oct 28, 2010

The deal with the mist is that my idea here is that he's coming out of the ground, there is mist behind him and a little bit in front of him.  You really think the Spanish moss needs to be darkened?  In real life it's much lighter than the trees it hangs from...kind of a dusty gray color.

That's what I thought, wouldn't the mist be coming over his shoulders and around the arms and over the hands in that case. I don't think the spanish moss is a big deal, it was my last thought. A zombie on all hallows eve coming to get us. Wonderful.

on Oct 28, 2010

You're right about the mist, but here's my hesitation on adding more -- with the background blurred and the foreground clear, (at least on my new widescreen monitor) there is this fabulous 3-d kind of effect, like he's coming right out of my monitor.  If I add more mist, I'm going to lose the clarity in the foreground, which will diminish that effect. 

I guess I need to play around some more with this.  (DANG day job for getting in the way!) LOL

on Oct 28, 2010

If I add more mist, I'm going to lose the clarity in the foreground, which will diminish that effect.

You need a little more in the foreground for depth. Change the focus (blur- use Lens blur or smart blur) and then some mist behind him and adjust the blur accordingly. Try a 'whispy smoke' brush or freehand for more depth and texture. ****You have mail

on Oct 28, 2010

Okay, devils advocate again. Are you working in this small a resolution or is that just the preview shot? I thought he was crawling on the ground. If he is to be coming out of the ground should not your terrain be a bit more around his torso on the sides?

I used to come home from work and spend so much time dinking with my graphics at night that getting up in the morning was a chore! I would give anything to go back there again. Losing my job has devastated me mentally and physically.

on Oct 28, 2010

I can be 'critical' when it comes to commenting on walls....

I can even be mildly 'diplomatic' in ascribing variations of 'this is crap'.

Or...

WHEN it's 'crap' I can always tell you it is crap.

 

 

If you wish.

But...

Most people will dismiss negativity/criticism as the ramblings of the inane...and will run for the comfort of their 'eager followers'.

WHEN an artist encounters criticism [negative] he will make a public noise of 'thankyou for your assistence/suggestions/input' but will ALWAYS privately [sometimes publicly] be thinking "WTF would HE know, anyway?".

 

Then the critic  has to demonstrate his qualification and that, TOO will be dismissed.

It's a bit like that overacted...."The truth?  You can't handle the truth." .....

on Oct 28, 2010
Bollocks...IE9 vs. WC ....doesn't do edits..."assistance" ... Spell checker
on Oct 28, 2010

WHEN an artist encounters criticism [negative] he will make a public noise of 'thankyou for your assistence/suggestions/input' but will ALWAYS privately [sometimes publicly] be thinking "WTF would HE know, anyway?".

I have to disagree a bit on that, If I can clearly see that the criticism is valid and has merits and is from what I consider a qualified individual, I try to learn from the critique instead of taking offense. It was not always that way, but I have long ago learned that I am not always my best critic. I would value your opinion at any time.

on Oct 29, 2010

PoSmedley

You need a little more in the foreground for depth. Change the focus (blur- use Lens blur or smart blur) and then some mist behind him and adjust the blur accordingly. Try a 'whispy smoke' brush or freehand for more depth and texture. ****You have mail


You really are that freakin' awesome, Po.

. Are you working in this small a resolution or is that just the preview shot?

No, I'm working with a huge file, 3000x2400 or something in that range -- that's just a preview shot (which is the biggest size Photobucket will upload for free, so that's why the preview shot is that size).

Most people will dismiss negativity/criticism as the ramblings of the inane...and will run for the comfort of their 'eager followers'.


At first, perhaps, but after they've grown and learned a little more, they would like to go back to getting the negative criticism so their art can improve--so if my wall looks like crap, please tell me about it, Jafo.  (It takes some of us a little longer to learn to accept criticism and not take it as a personal offense).

on Oct 29, 2010

At first, perhaps, but after they've grown and learned a little more, they would like to go back to getting the negative criticism so their art can improve--so if my wall looks like crap, please tell me about it, Jafo. (It takes some of us a little longer to learn to accept criticism and not take it as a personal offense).

Amen to that!

on Oct 29, 2010

OK - I've made adjustments, thanks to the great advice I received in this thread.  Any thoughts?

on Oct 29, 2010

Hide all the breakables! That guy looks hungry. Very realistic k10w3. Are his eyes open or closed. They look closed. If so maybe having them open will lend more macabre to it, make it look more menacing.

on Oct 29, 2010

His eyes are totally open, Uvah. 

18 PagesFirst 5 6 7 8 9  Last